HobbyGM

PSA vs CGC

PSA costs more and resells best; CGC is far cheaper and strong for Pokémon. Here's how to choose, card by card.

Checked October 14, 2026

PSACGC
Cheapest tier$59.99 Standard (Value tiers paused)$17 Bulk (25 cards, up to $500 each)
Mid tier$79.99 Priority$55 Standard
Fast tier$199 Express$100 Express
Share of graded sports listings on eBay74%3%
Share of graded card-game listings on eBay79%11%

Listing shares from HobbyGM's eBay market snapshot, November 18, 2026.

Choose PSA when

  • The card's value depends on a gem grade. A PSA 10 usually sells for more than a CGC 10 of the same card.
  • You're selling sports cards, where PSA is on most graded listings and CGC on only a few percent.
  • You want the widest pool of buyers and the easiest resale.

Choose CGC when

  • You're grading many mid-value cards, where $17 Bulk against $59.99 is the whole margin.
  • It's Pokémon or another card game, where CGC is the clear number two and widely accepted.
  • You want the grade for protection or a personal collection more than for resale.

Run your own card through the grading calculator with each company's price to see the difference in dollars.

Questions sellers ask

Is PSA or CGC better for Pokémon cards?
PSA resells best and is on most graded Pokémon listings; CGC is much cheaper and is the clear second choice in card games. For expensive cards, PSA; for volume, CGC.
Is CGC cheaper than PSA?
Yes, at every level in 2026: $17 Bulk against PSA's $59.99 Standard, and $100 Express against PSA's $199.

Get the HobbyGM newsletter

Selling tips, new free tools and card market data for eBay card sellers, about twice a month.

Unsubscribe any time. See our privacy policy.