HobbyGM

Where to sell sports cards

The best place to sell a sports card depends on what it's worth, whether it's graded, and how much of the work you want to do yourself. Here's how the main options compare on fees and effort, and which cards suit each.

Published October 2, 2026 · Checked October 2, 2026

Written, edited and reviewed by Rory Hansen

At a glance

WhereBest forSeller feesWho does the work
eBayAlmost everything: raw and graded singles, lots, sealed13.25% of the total plus $0.30 or $0.40 an orderYou list and ship
COMCMany raw or graded singles from a few dollars to about $50Intake fee per card, a fee on each sale, and a fee to cash outCOMC photographs, lists and ships
Fanatics CollectGraded cards, mid-range to high-end6% on fairly priced Buy Now listings; 0% if paid in FanCashCards sit in their vault; they ship
AltGraded cards14% under $250, falling to 5% at $10,000 and upCards sit in their vault; they ship
MySlabsMid-value slabs1% on slabs, 3% on raw, plus payment feesYou ship
My Card PostSellers who want lower fees than eBay5% on the free plan; 0% on paid plans from $9.99 a month; PayPal fees on every saleYou ship
WhatnotSellers who want to sell liveA commission plus payment processingYou stream and ship
Goldin, HeritageHigh-end and vintageNegotiated commission; buyers pay a premiumThey photograph, list and ship
FacebookLocal sales and groupsFree locally; 10% on shipped sales through Meta checkoutYou list and ship or meet
Card shops and showsBulk, whole collections, quick cashNo fee, but offers are well below marketThey do nothing; you get paid on the spot

Fees as of October 2, 2026 (My Card Post's as of November 17, 2026). They change often, so check the platform's own page before you send it cards.

Bulk and commons

Cards worth under a dollar or two lose money listed one at a time on any platform, once fees and postage come out. Sell them as lots (by team, player, set or year), or to a shop or a dealer at a show. See selling $1 cards on eBay for the exceptions.

Raw singles from a few dollars to about $50

eBay has the most buyers for these, and cards under $20 ship cheaply by Standard Envelope. You do the work: photos, listing and shipping. Here's how to list sports cards on eBay.

COMC does that work for you. You mail in your cards and pay an intake fee per card: on its Standard service (about 16 weeks, 100-card minimum) that's $0.65 for a raw card and $1.25 for a graded one, more for faster service. COMC's fee page also lists a fee when a card sells and a fee to cash out your balance, so on a $3 card most of the money goes in fees. It suits a big stack of $5 to $50 cards you'll never get round to listing.

Graded cards

eBay is the deepest market for slabs: on November 18, 2026, 35,089 graded sports cards were newly listed there in a single day, 74% of them PSA. Cards sold for $200 or more go through eBay's Authenticity Guarantee.

The alternatives trade a smaller audience for lower fees or less work:

  • Fanatics Collect (formerly PWCC) holds cards in its vault. Its Buy Now fee is 6% when your price is within 120% of market value. Since July 2026 US sellers pay no seller fee if they take payment as FanCash, which can only be spent at Fanatics. Vault withdrawal fees apply if you take a card out.
  • Alt also works from a vault. Fixed-price fees are 14% from $1 to $249, 9% from $250 to $7,499, 7% from $7,500 to $9,999, and 5% at $10,000 and up.
  • MySlabs charges 1% on slabs and 3% on raw cards, plus PayPal fees, but has far fewer buyers. Expect cards to take longer to sell.

Lower fees than eBay: My Card Post

My Card Post's pitch is that you keep more of each sale. On its free plan it takes 5%; on a paid plan (from $9.99 a month, or $7.99 a month billed yearly) it takes nothing. PayPal's processing fee comes out either way: My Card Post's own FAQ works it at 3.49% plus $0.49. On a $100 card that leaves you about $91 on the free plan and $96 on a paid plan, against about $86 on eBay. So you can price around 10% under the eBay comps and still come out even or ahead, and that lower price is what pulls buyers over. A paid plan covers its own cost once you sell about $200 a month there.

The catch is reach: it has far fewer buyers than eBay, so a card can take longer to sell, and many sellers list on both. It takes raw and graded cards. Fixed-price listings and offers work on every plan; auctions and trades need a paid plan.

High-end cards

For cards worth thousands, an auction house can bring more bidders than a single eBay listing. Goldin (owned by eBay since 2024) takes weekly-auction consignments from $100 and Elite consignments from $7,500. Heritage runs sports auctions too. Both charge buyers a premium on top of the hammer price, and seller commission is negotiated, so get the terms in writing and compare them with what you'd keep on eBay.

Whatnot and live selling

Whatnot charges a commission and payment processing on each sale, and pays off for sellers who build an audience that comes back to watch. It isn't a good place to sell one card: prices depend on who's in the room.

Facebook, card shops and shows

Facebook Marketplace is free for local sales; shipped sales through Meta's checkout pay 10% (minimum $0.80). Card groups often trade by PayPal, where you're on your own if something goes wrong.

A card shop or a dealer at a show pays on the spot, but well below market. Around half of market value is a commonly quoted rule of thumb for cash, with less for bulk and more for desirable graded cards. Store credit is usually worth more than cash if you're buying anyway.

Selling a whole collection

  1. Sort by sport, then by year and set. It makes everything after this faster.
  2. Pull the cards worth selling on their own: stars, rookies, graded cards, anything that has sold for more than a few dollars. Check sold prices, not asking prices.
  3. List or consign those singles. Consider whether any are worth grading first.
  4. Sell the rest as lots, or take a dealer's offer for the remainder.

Selling the lot to one dealer is the fastest option and pays the least. Doing it yourself pays the most and takes the longest.

Sources

Questions sellers ask

What's the best place to sell sports cards?
For most raw and graded singles, eBay: it has by far the most buyers, and you keep roughly 85% after fees. If you'd rather not list and ship cards yourself, COMC handles that for a fee. Very high-end cards can do better at an auction house.
How much will a card shop pay for my cards?
Less than you'd get selling them yourself. Cash offers of around half of market value are a commonly quoted rule of thumb, often less for bulk and more for desirable graded cards. Store credit is usually higher than cash.
Is COMC worth it?
For lots of cards worth a few dollars to about $50 that you don't want to photograph, list and ship yourself, often yes. You pay an intake fee per card, a fee when it sells, and a fee to cash out, so check what's left on cheap cards.
Where should I sell an inherited sports card collection?
Sort it first. Pull the few cards worth selling on their own and list or consign those; sell the rest as lots or to a dealer. Selling everything to one dealer is fastest but pays least.

Get the HobbyGM newsletter

Selling tips, new free tools and card market data for eBay card sellers, about twice a month.

Unsubscribe any time. See our privacy policy.